When I told my friend that our new book is called Can a Catholic Be a Democrat?, he shot back, “Can a Catholic be a Republican?”
That’s a good question, since these days both parties endorse policies or engage in activities that contradict some or many Catholic teachings about abortion, poverty, immigration, war and peace, or other issues of life and justice.
But that’s not always been the case.
Indeed, when author David Carlin was a young man, it was scandalous for a good Catholic to be anything but a good Democrat. In the pews, pubs, and union halls of America’s cities, millions of poor European immigrants and their children pledged allegiance to the Church of Rome and the party of FDR.
All that changed in the 1960s, with the rise of a new kind of Democrat: wealthy, secular, ideological. Even as Carlin served the party he loved — twelve years as a Rhode Island state senator and once a candidate for Congress — he could only watch in dismay as its national leaders abandoned their blue-collar, pro-life, and religious constituencies and took up with NOW, Hollywood, and the abortion lobby.
So complete has been this transformation that we no longer speak of a natural alliance between Catholics and the Democratic Party.
Indeed, ever increasing numbers of Democrats are joining the ranks of us voters for whom “voting Catholic” means holding our nose and choosing the candidates in either party whose views are least hostile to our faith.
In recent years, the conflict between his faith and the policies of his party has grown so marked that author Carlin, a cradle Catholic, lifetime Democrat, and longtime Democratic legislator, now feels compelled to consider in his new book whether, in good conscience, it’s even possible to be both a faithful Catholic and a Democratic true believer.
But Can a Catholic Be a Democrat? isn’t partisan.
By considering the changes that have taken place in his own party these past fifty years (and that some would now bring about in the Republican Party, too), Carlin identifies the fundamental policies that we as Catholics must support, and the ones that we Catholics must never abide — so that, regardless of our party affiliation, we can prudently work for (and will have the opportunity to vote for) policies consistent with our faith.
What about the Democrats?
Carlin, a veteran sociologist, philosophy professor, and author of The Decline and Fall of the Catholic Church in America, shows that his party and his religion have now taken opposite sides in the Culture War.
He argues that on issues of human life, sex, faith, morality, suffering — and the public policies that stem from them — the modern, secularist Democratic Party has become the enemy of Catholicism; indeed, of all traditional religions.
Carlin shatters the excuses that Catholic Democratic politicians employ in a vain attempt to reconcile their faith and their votes, and then, with what he calls the “political equivalent of a broken heart,” he examines his own political conscience. As a faithful Catholic and a Democrat approaching his seventieth year, must he now leave the party he’s called home since birth?
David Carlin’s arguments challenge all religious voters to ask themselves the same question.
Carlin’s clear and gracious arguments may not lead you to a more Catholic party, but they’ll help you explain Catholic positions to your friends, relatives, and fellow party members; and they’ll help you make your own party less hostile to the beliefs of Catholics.
That’s important, because these days Catholic voters are the swing voters who determine the winners in close elections. The people who hear Carlin’s voice today will win elections tomorrow.
You can help.
Order Carlin’s book today, and buy extras to give to your undecided relatives and friends.
Read an excerpt.
A Well-Researched Book on the Evolution of the Democratic Party
Lest anyone think this is an apologetic for the Republican Party, I should clarify that the author does not call all Catholics to be Republicans. Becoming Republican is not the proposed solution to the problem explored in this work. Rather, David Carlin leaves the solution to his readers. Carlin himself has not switched parties and states clearly in the introduction, "I expect to die a Democrat, albeit a very unhappy one." He writes not as a hostile outsider, but rather—as one reader observed—as a wounded lover betrayed by his beloved.
A lifelong Democrat, Carlin entered professional politics and became the majority leader of the Rhode Island State Senate. Born in 1938 into an Irish Catholic working-class family, Carlin remembers his father telling him, "We’re Democrats because Democrats are the party of the poor people; the Republicans are the party of the rich." He believes no political party in modern times has had a program a Full Review...
Msgr. Georges Lemaitre - Priest of Heroic Virtue 02/05/2010
Indulgences for the Year of the Priest 06/05/2009
The Year of the Priest 06/04/2009
January 22 - A Day of Prayer and Penance for Life 01/14/2009
Catholic Schools Week 01/14/2009
Respect Life Sunday 10/03/2008
About the Battle of Lepanto 10/01/2008
The Women Who Led the Way 04/01/1996